Skip to main content

Table 3 Pearson correlation between the true and predicted genomic breeding values for group bridge, MCP, lasso and SCAD for trait T3 based on systematic groups.

From: Regularized group regression methods for genomic prediction: Bridge, MCP, SCAD, group bridge, group lasso, sparse group lasso, group MCP and group SCAD

Group size

Penalty selected by AIC

Penalty selected by BIC

 

Bridge

MCP

Lasso

SCAD

SGLasso

Bridge

MCP

Lasso

SCAD

1

0.811

0.818

0.818

0.796

0.807

0.812

0.813

0.814

0.716

10

0.742

0.818

0.835

0.816

0.814

0.742

0.813

0.776

0.763

20

0.776

0.818

0.814

0.794

0.814

0.766

0.813

0.742

0.735

30

0.801

0.818

0.818

0.818

0.814

0.791

0.813

0.742

0.742

40

0.812

0.818

0.804

0.797

0.814

0.790

0.813

0.725

0.725

50

0.809

0.817

0.814

0.818

0.816

0.801

0.813

0.716

0.716

60

0.825

0.817

0.802

0.813

0.817

0.808

0.813

0.712

0.712

70

0.822

0.816

0.806

0.816

0.815

0.806

0.813

0.710

0.710

80

0.824

0.816

0.795

0.788

0.816

0.807

0.813

0.686

0.686

90

0.803

0.818

0.793

0.776

0.816

0.817

0.813

0.665

0.598

100

0.820

0.817

0.791

0.764

0.797

0.760

0.813

0.776

0.665

  1. Although listed under AIC, SGLasso used only 10-fold cross validation. The Pearson correlation for ridge regression for comparison is 0.762.